If you're looking for a special dining experience in Bay Shore, NY, look no further than these top 10 private dining rooms. These restaurants offer a charming and intimate setting for your next special occasion, whether it's a romantic dinner for two or a family celebration. Each one offers a unique atmosphere and menu, ensuring a memorable and delicious dining experience.Experience Fine Dining in Private at These Bay Shore Restaurants
Captain Bill's is a popular seafood restaurant that also offers a private dining room for parties and events. The room is elegantly decorated and can accommodate up to 50 guests. The menu features a variety of fresh seafood dishes, as well as steaks and pasta options. Make sure to try their famous Lobster Bisque and surf and turf entrees for a truly indulgent meal.Captain Bill's
For a more casual but still upscale private dining experience, check out Fatfish Wine Bar and Bistro. Their private room can accommodate up to 25 guests and features a cozy fireplace and wine cellar. The menu offers a variety of small plates, perfect for sharing with a group, as well as larger entrees like braised short ribs and pan-seared salmon.Fatfish Wine Bar and Bistro
Tullulah's is a charming neighborhood bistro that also offers a private dining room for up to 30 guests. The room is warm and inviting, with exposed brick walls and elegant chandeliers. The menu features classic American dishes with a modern twist, like their short rib mac and cheese and truffle mushroom risotto. Don't forget to save room for their decadent desserts, like the s'mores bread pudding.Tullulah's
As the name suggests, The Lake House offers stunning views of the Great South Bay and a private dining room for up to 35 guests. The room is beautifully decorated with a nautical theme and features a cozy fireplace. The menu showcases fresh seafood dishes, like their crab-stuffed flounder and lobster ravioli, as well as hearty steaks and pastas.The Lake House
The Oar is a popular spot for seafood lovers, and their private dining room is perfect for a special occasion. The room can accommodate up to 40 guests and has a rustic charm with exposed wood beams and a stone fireplace. The menu offers a variety of fresh seafood dishes, as well as their famous prime rib and filet mignon.The Oar Steak and Seafood Grill
The Snapper Inn is a waterfront restaurant with a private dining room that can accommodate up to 60 guests. The room features stunning views of the Connetquot River and a warm and inviting atmosphere. The menu focuses on fresh seafood, with dishes like sesame crusted tuna and pan-seared scallops, as well as land options like roasted duck breast and filet mignon.The Snapper Inn
For a more casual private dining experience, check out The Grey Horse Tavern. Their private room can accommodate up to 25 guests and features a cozy fireplace and vintage decor. The menu offers a variety of American comfort food, like their buttermilk fried chicken and braised short ribs, as well as a great selection of craft beers and cocktails.The Grey Horse Tavern
The Post Office Cafe offers a private dining room for up to 30 guests, perfect for a small gathering with friends or family. The room is decorated with historic photos and memorabilia from the building's past as a post office. The menu features classic American dishes, like homemade meatloaf and chicken parmesan, as well as a variety of burgers and sandwiches.The Post Office Cafe
With its stunning waterfront views and private dining room for up to 35 guests, The Lake House is worth a second mention on this list. The restaurant also offers a private outdoor patio for larger events. The menu features fresh seafood dishes, as well as a variety of meats and pastas. Don't miss their extensive wine list and delicious desserts.The Lake House